Osmanlı’da Kamu Bankacılığı, Kırsal Kredi Tahsisi ve Yerel Politik Ekonomi: Ziraat Bankası Kredilerinin Dağılımı,
40. Maliye Sempozyumu, Antalya, Türkiye, 22 - 24 Ekim 2026, ss.1-5, (Özet Bildiri)
- Yayın Türü: Bildiri / Özet Bildiri
- Basıldığı Şehir: Antalya
- Basıldığı Ülke: Türkiye
- Sayfa Sayıları: ss.1-5
- Kocaeli Üniversitesi Adresli: Evet
Özet
Public Banking, Rural Credit Allocation, and the
Local Political Economy in the Ottoman Empire: The Distribution of Ziraat Bank
Loans, 1888–1914[1]
Avni Önder
Hanedar[2] Işıl Ayas[3] (12-point font)
Keywords (10-point font): Ziraat Bank, public banking, rural
credit, Ottoman public finance, political economy
JEL Codes (10-point font): N23, H81, G21
Significance of
the Study (12-point font): Established
during the final period of the Ottoman Empire to support agricultural
production, increase access to finance in rural areas, and free producers from
dependence on usurious loans, the Ziraat Bank is one of the early examples of
modern public banking. The fact that the bank’s resources were linked to the
ashâr tax makes credit allocation not only a financial but also a fiscal issue.
This study examines the Agricultural Bank as a fiscal policy tool illustrating
how public resources were distributed at the local level and offers a
historical and empirical contribution to discussions on Ottoman public finance,
state capacity, financial inclusion, and regional development.
Purpose of the
Study (12-point font): The
purpose of this study is to examine the economic, social, and political
dynamics that governed the allocation of Ziraat Bank loans in the Ottoman
Empire during the period 1888–1914. The study examines whether credit
allocation was determined solely by economic factors—such as agricultural
needs, production capacity, and market access—or by local administrators,
guarantee relationships, political connections, security issues, and the local
functioning of public authority. Thus, the study analyzes whether public
banking served as an inclusive mechanism supporting rural development or as a
selective resource allocation tool shaped by local power relations.
Literature (12-point
font): Access
to credit is recognized as a fundamental prerequisite for agricultural
commercialization and increased rural productivity. In economies where formal
financial institutions are limited, small producers face high borrowing costs;
this situation restricts input use, product diversification, and market
integration (Guinnane, 2001; Colvin and McLaughlin, 2014). Experiences with
cooperative banking in Europe—particularly the Raiffeisen model—hold a
significant place in the literature for providing credit to small producers
through local organization and the principles of mutual responsibility (Kumar
et al., 2010). In the literature on Ottoman economic history, the Memleket
Sandıkları, the “ ” Menafi Sandıkları, and the Ziraat Bank have mostly been
examined in the context of institutional development, agricultural
modernization, and the state’s fiscal capacity (Atasağun, 1939; Güran, 1998).
However, there are few studies that quantitatively examine the economic,
financial, and political factors influencing the distribution of Ziraat Bank
loans at the local level.
Design and Method (12-point font): This study is designed as
an applied, historical, and empirical research project. The analysis will
utilize Agricultural Bank balance sheet data from the period 1889–1914. These
data include indicators such as loan amounts, non-performing loans, types of
collateral, mortgage loans, and personal guarantee loans at the province,
sanjak, district, and branch levels. Two main types of loans provided by the
Agricultural Bank to farmers will be given special attention: mortgage loans
secured by movable or immovable property and personal guarantee loans provided
through local guarantors.
The
loan data will be combined with indicators such as population, agricultural
production patterns, tax-paying capacity, railroad connectivity, market access,
the presence of bankers, local uprisings, security issues, administrative
changes, and political representation. The study’s main research questions are
as follows: Were Ziraat Bank loans distributed according to economic needs? Do
the determinants of mortgage loans differ from those of personal guarantee
loans? Did the local political and administrative structure influence loan
allocation? Did the distribution of public resources play a role in reducing or
increasing regional inequalities? The methodology will include cross-sectional
and panel data regressions, fixed-effects models, spatial analyses, and
robustness checks.
Findings and Discussion (12-point
font):
Preliminary findings regarding the 1909 Turkey sample are presented in
Table 1.
Table 1. Preliminary assessment for the 1909 Turkey sample.
|
Variables |
Total
Credit per Person |
Per Capita
Credit Secured by Pledge |
Credit per
Capita Secured by Personal Guarantee |
|
Railroad |
-4,422
(0.965) |
91,596
(0.372) |
76,433**
(0.017) |
|
Public Debt
Branch |
-51,221
(0.583) |
76,790
(0.328) |
-5,205
(0.858) |
|
Per Capita
Commercial Agricultural Production |
0.965**
(0.009) |
0.879*
(0.085) |
0.202
(0.345) |
|
Number of
Banks |
-0.077
(0.926) |
-0.252
(0.803) |
-0.634
(0.129) |
|
Rebellion/War |
-25.984
(0.746) |
-153.204*
(0.121) |
-85.837***
(0.005) |
|
Number of
Committee of Union and Progress Members of Parliament |
-174,231***
(0.002) |
-101,386*
(0.054) |
40,137**
(0.043) |
|
Proximity
to the Sea |
220,256**
(0.020) |
161,190*
(0.073) |
22,636
(0.528) |
|
Elevation |
-0.291***
(0.003) |
-0.279***
(0.001) |
0.094***
(0.001) |
|
Steepness |
0.731***
(0.002) |
0.564**
(0.013) |
-0.079
(0.338) |
|
Arable Land
per Person |
71.936
(0.195) |
89.328**
(0.031) |
25.286
(0.111) |
|
Constant |
709,864***
(0.001) |
932,830***
(0.000) |
-3,567
(0.957) |
|
R² |
0.46 |
0.47 |
0.20 |
|
N |
199 |
199 |
199 |
Notes: Values in parentheses indicate p-values. Significance
levels are indicated as follows: *, **, *** denote significance
at the 1%, 5%, and 10% levels, respectively. Standard errors were calculated
using clustering at the provincial level. Covers regions outside Istanbul. The
dataset was compiled from the Ziraat Bank Statistical Journal/Ledger, Dersaadet
Printing House, Istanbul, 1909.
The findings indicate that Ziraat Bank loans were shaped
not only by economic needs but also by political, institutional, and geographic
factors. The negative and statistically significant effect of rebellion/war,
particularly on personal guarantee loans, suggests that political instability
limited access to credit. The number of Committee of Union and Progress (CUP)
members in parliament had a negative effect on total and collateralized loans
but a positive effect on personally guaranteed loans. This finding suggests
that political networks and local relationships may play a role in personally
guaranteed loans directed toward small producers, and that there may be
inefficiencies in the allocation of tax revenues through the Agricultural Bank.
Conclusions and Recommendations
(12-point font): This
study empirically evaluates how public banking functioned in the Ottoman Empire
in terms of rural development, financial resource allocation, and state
capacity. The findings suggest that the potential of public banks to reduce
regional inequalities and increase financial inclusion may be constrained by
local institutional structures, security conditions, and political
relationships. This historical analysis offers a comparative perspective for
contemporary discussions on public banking, agricultural support policies, the
regional distribution of public resources, and development finance.
References:
Atasağun,
Y. S. (1939). The Agricultural Bank of the Republic of Turkey, 1888–1939.
Istanbul: Kenan Basımevi.
Colvin,
C. L., & McLaughlin, E. (2014). Raiffeisenism abroad: Why did German
cooperative banking fail in Ireland but prosper in the Netherlands? The
Economic History Review, 67(2), 492–516.
Guinnane,
T. W. (2001). Cooperatives as information machines: German rural credit
cooperatives, 1883–1914. The Journal of Economic History, 61(2),
366–389.
Güran,
T. (1998). 19th-Century Ottoman Agriculture. Istanbul: Eren Kitabevi.
Kumar,
A., Singh, K. M., & Sinha, S. (2010). Institutional credit to the
agricultural sector in India: Status, performance, and determinants. Agricultural
Economics Research Review, 23(2), 253–264.
[1] This study is based on data obtained from
TUBİTAK Project No. 967236.
[2] Associate Professor, Sakarya University,
Department of Econometrics, Esentepe Campus, Serdivan/Sakarya, ORCID:
0000-0002-1281-2116, onderhanedar@sakarya.edu.tr.
[3] Associate Professor, Sakarya University,
Department of Finance, Esentepe Campus, Serdivan/Sakarya, ORCID:
0000-0002-5441-006X, iyeter@sakarya.edu.tr